Transdermal Drug Therapy- A Novel Approach for Acne
Vulgaris Treatment
Saurabh Tiwari*, Shweta Singh, Dr. Pushpendra
Kumar Tripathi, Mr. Chetan
Kumar Dubey
Rameshwaram
Institute of Technology and Management, Lucknow.
*Corresponding
Author E-mail: tiwari.saurabh252@gmail.com
ABSTRACT:
Acne vulgaris,
one of the skin inflammatory disorders, is most common among youths of various
countries including India, countries of U.S and U.K. It is caused by the
colonization of Propionibacterium acnes, following
with other factors in the skin. This disorder also causes mental disturbances
to the patient. Therefore, it is very necessary to cure this disease in an
effective manner. Transdermal therapy, a novel
approach to cure skin inflammatory diseases, has contributed a big step which
allows drug molecules to passively diffuse through the skin surface without
damaging the deeper tissues. It has overcome all the disadvantages of general
topical therapy and hypodermic injections and gained more attention among
researchers and patient.
KEYWORDS:
Acne
vulgaris, transdermal dryg therapy, transdermal
patches, microneedles.
INTRODUCTION:
Human skin has been considered as the
largest organ as well as one of the most important physiological barriers of
the body for different types of causative agents responsible for various skin
inflammatory diseases. It is made up of epidermis, known as stratum corneum which is the outermost layer (major barrier of the
skin); dermis, just lower the epidermis; hypodermis, next to the dermis and
skin appendages, mainly contain hair follicles with associated sebaceous
glands, eccrine and apocrine
sweat gland and nails. Each layer in the skin has its own function for protecting
the body against infectious diseases and maintaining the texture of the skin,
temperature and pH of the body (13, 6). From
the various skin inflammatory diseases, acne vulgaris
is most common. Initially, the pathological condition of acne vulgaris can be observed in the form of microscopic micro come
do; which can later, develops in the form of come dones,
papules, pustules and cyst on the pilosebaceous units
of the skin. Although, acne vulgar is multifactoral,
interplay activity of four well known factors have been observed as a major
cause of this skin disorder. A surplus of sebum production secondary to
sebaceous gland hyperplasia; faulty keratinization of
epidermal hair follicles, causes hyper proliferation of follicles and formation
of an in apparent micro come do and accumulation of lipids and cellular debris
inside the blocked follicles encourages the enhancement in concentration and
action of a bacterium, Propionibacterium acnes. The
action of this bacterium triggers both adaptive and innate immunity with the
activation of inflammatory cascade including cytokines and chemokines,
along with neutrophils inflammatory factors. The
result of inflammation is observed by enhancement in follicular rupture and
subsequent leakage of lipids, bacteria, and fatty acids into the dermis.
Besides it, it has been noticed that the action of keratinocytes
and sebocytes in the developing acne vulgaris. Both the cells express Toll-like receptors
(pattern recognition receptors) which recognize pathogen associated molecular
pattern to induce innate immunity, necessary for pathogenesis of acne. Sebocytes are also able to induce innate immune response by
activating lipid metabolism. Lesions of acne vulgaris
can be observed on the areas of the neck, face, chest, upper arms and back
because there is the highest concentration of sebaceous glands. A long with the
internal factors, some external factors like mechanical obstruction (i.e.,
helmets, shirt collars), occupational exposures, or medications can induce the
formation of acne. Hormonal imbalances are also capable in developing acne
flares in women, during premenstrual times, and with an increased level in
androgens, either from an adrenal or ovarian source. Excessive use of anabolic
steroids can also trigger acne flares in men (4, 10, 13). Effect of various
medications can also develop the condition of acne which has listed below in
the table:
Table
1: Medications Responsible to Trigger Acne Development in Men
More Commonly |
Less Commonly |
Anabolic
Steroids ·
Testosterone ·
Danazol (Danocrine) |
Azathioprin (Imuran) |
Bromides |
Cyclosporin ·
Sandimmune ·
Neoral |
Corticosteroids ·
Prednisone (Deltasone) |
Disulfram (Antabuse) |
Corticotropin |
Phenobarbitol |
Isoniazid (Nydrazid) |
Quinidine |
Lithium |
Tetracycline |
Phenytoin (Dilantin) |
Vitamin
B1, B6, B12 and D2 |
Referenced by Steven Feldman,
Rachel E. Careccia, Kelly L. Barham,
and John Hancox (2004). Diagnosis and Treatment of
Acne. American Academy of Family Physicians (69: 2123-30, 2135-6)
For the treatment of acne vulgaris topical therapy has been applied on the affected
areas. Various retinoids like adapalene
(differin), tazarotene (tazorac), tretinoin (retin-A), tertinoin microsphere
(micro) have been used in the treatment. Clindamycin
(generic), arithromycin like antibiotics are also
involved in the treatment of acne vulgaris (4, 7, 10,
13). The following table which has showed below is able to describe the
formulation and side effects of the applied medications:
Table
2: Medications used for the Treatment of Acne vulgaris
and their side effects
Medications |
Side
effects |
Retinoids ·
Adapalene
(Differin) ·
Tazarotene
(Tazorac) ·
Tretinoin
(Retin-A) ·
Tretinoin
microsphere (Retin-A Micro) |
Dryness, scaling, erythema,
burning, irritation, and
photosensitivity |
Antibiotics ·
Clindamycin
(generic) ·
Erythromycin |
Local irritation; stains clothes |
Referenced
by Steven Feldman, Rachel E. Careccia, Kelly L. Barham, and John Hancox (2004).
Diagnosis and Treatment of Acne. American Academy of Family Physicians (69:
2123-30, 2135-6)
The topical therapy has not been considered
as a successful procedure to cure skin inflammatory diseases including acne vulgaris because of various side effects of the medications
used in the treatment of acne vulgaris. Besides it,
the major problem for the topical medication is the upper desquamating horny
layer of skin, stratum corneum (epidermis) acts as a
physiological barrier for the passage of foreign particles through the skin,
inside the body. Stratum corneum has thickness of
10-20 µm having approximately 15-25 layers of dead, flattened, keratinized,
stacked, cornified cells embedded in an intercellular
matrix of lipids. The complex structure made of lipid intercellular matrix
makes the epidermis a barrier to prevent transepidermal
water loss. Among other skin layers, this layer possesses a rate-limiting
barrier property for percutaneous drug transport.
Lipid richness and low water content inside the epidermis makes it difficult
for the passage of hydrophilic and charged molecules inside the skin. To
overcome these difficulties, intense studies of researchers have introduced transdermal drug therapy which is a new way for the
treatment and overall management of almost all kinds of skin inflammatory
disorders including acne vulgaris. This work is a
reviewed research applied on all the researches which have been done in the
treatment of acne vulgaris through transdermal therapy (2, 3, 4, 7).
Mechanism
of Introducing Transdermal Drugs:
Drug delivery from transdermal
systems have become more convenient, attractive and less painful way for both
researchers (to study) and patients. It has almost eliminated the concept of
oral administration of drugs and hypodermic injections; hence, made an
important contribution in the medical sciences. This therapy has been
categorized into three generations which described the advanced procedure of
delivering drugs as different kinds of the transdermal
drug therapy. First generations of transdermal system
have used transdermal patches which are able to
deliver small, lipophillic and low-dose drugs. Second
generations transdermal systems have introduced the
technique of chemical enhancers, non-cavitational
ultrasound and iontophoresis for drug delivery. Third
generations of transdermal systems have targeted the
uppermost layer of skin, the stratum corneum
(physiological skin barrier), to deliver drugs inside the human skin. These
systems include micro needles, thermal ablation, microdermabrasion,
electro oration and cavitational ultrasound. With
these advanced generations strategies, transdermal
therapy have gained more positive impact among various other disease management
methods (1, 5, 6, 9, 12).
First
Generation Transdermal System (Transdermal
Patches):
These products require a low molecular
weight, lipophillic and efficient drug molecules in
low doses. In transdermal patch designs, there is a
reservoir for the storage of drug which is enclosed with an impermeable backing
and has an adhesive which is able to make a contact with the skin. Water and
sweat prevents the patch from permanent adhesion. Some designs employ drug
dissolved in a liquid or gel-based reservoir, which can simplify formulations
and permit the use of liquid chemical enhancers, such as ethanol. Transport of
drug through stratum corneum follows passive
diffusion pathway through intercellular lipids via twisted winding around corneocytes. This includes movement of hydrophilic
molecules through lipid head group regions and lipophillic
molecules through lipid tails. Therefore, this overall pathway is compelled by
the requirements of structure and solubility of the drug molecule to diffuse
across lipid bilayer of stratum corneum.
There are some products available which diffuse transdermally
like the transdermal patches. These include metered
liquid spray, topical gels or other topical formulations that deliver small lipophillic drug into the stratum corneum
after evaporation and absorption of the drug, which in turn, serve as a drug
reservoir for over 10 hours. A transdermal spray to
deliver estradiol is has been recently approved (5,
9, 11, 12). In a recenty study, it has been observed
that tretinoin in proniosome
colloidal vesicle have been used to treat acne vulgaris
to reduce the problem of skin irritation (3).
Second
Generation Transdermal Systems:
To increase skin permeability and
reducing skin irritation, these transdermal systems
have been developed. Conventional chemical enhancers have been designed in such
a way that can easily disrupt the bilayer structured
intracellular lipids found in stratum corneum with
the help of integrating amphiphilic molecules into
it, which then extract out lipids from the matrix of uppermost layer or
disorganize the packing of the entire cellular matrix. Other molecules like liposomes, micro emulsions, prodrugs
and dendrimers have also been developed as a chemical
enhancer, which are capable in enhancing drug solubilization
in the formulation, increasing drug lipophilicity and
portioning of drug into the skin (9, 12).
Iontophoresis, another technique in second generation transdermal drug delivery, transport drugs by an electrical
driving force across stratum corneum. In this
technique, charged drug are moved with the help of electrophoresis while weakly
charged or uncharged compounds prefer their movement by the electrosomotic
flow of water produced due to the movement of mobile cations
like Na+ instead of fixed anions like keratins in the stratum corneum. These small charged molecules and some
macromolecules are able to change the skin barrier effect. The major advantage
of this technique is high rate of drug delivery with the electric current which
can be turned off or turned on and even modulated according the drug delivery
profiles (9, 12).
Non-cavitational
ultrasound, one of the advanced techniques in second generation transdermal systems that are able to deliver drugs more
efficiently with the effect of pressure gradient and oscillations associated
with ultrasound, which acts as a driving force to drug delivery by disrupting
stratum corneum lipid structure and thereby enhancing
skin permeability to that drug (9, 12).
Third
Generation Transdermal Systems:
These transdermal
systems have been created to deliver drugs more effectively across the stratum corneum without damaging the deeper tissues. Various
techniques have been designed in it. Eletroporation,
a technique in third generation transdermal systems,
disrupts lipid bilayer structure of the skin by electrophoretic force (applied for milliseconds). The
diffusion of drugs by the effect of this technique can persist for up to hours,
resulting in an increased magnitude of transdermal
products (9).
Cavitational
ultrasound, another transdermal technique, a coupling
medium (hydrogel) is used to allow oscillating the
bubbles within densely packed tissue, between the ultrasound transducer and
skin. These bubbles collapse at the skin surface and generate localized shock
waves and liquid microjets towards stratum corneum. Due to the disruption of stratum corneum, the permeability for the drug is increased up to
several hours (9, 12).
Micro needles therapy, also known as
collagen induction therapy or percutaneous collagen
induction (PCI), has been proved very useful in the treatment of acne scars. With this technique,
high molecular weight drugs can be easily introduced through the skin, by
creating micropores from micro needles, without
disturbing the dermal nerves. This method increases the skin permeability for
many compounds, ranging from small chemicals to nano-sized
molecules. Depending upon the length of micro needle, the opening and the
reversible nature of micro channels vary (close within few hours). Reversible
nature of micro channels is very useful for the therapeutic compounds or cosmetic
agent delivery in a controlled manner (8, 9, 12).
Thermal ablation, provide selective
heating to the surface of the skin for generating micron-scale perforations
into the stratum corneum. Heating for microseconds to
milliseconds at hundreds of degrees is responsible for transfer of heat to skin
surface without affecting the viable tissues below. Rapid vaporizing of water
into the stratum corneum occurs in such a manner
which results in volumetric expansion in the skin’s surface (9, 12).
Microdermabrasion, a
final way in which tissues has been removed and altered for cosmetic purposes.
This method is related to sand blasting at microscopic level, to increase the
skin permeability for drugs (9, 12).
Adverse
Effects of Transdermal Drug Therapy
A long with various benefits, there are
certain weaknesses of transdermal therapy. As there
are various advanced techniques introduced in the transdermal
therapy to overcome the problem of skin irritation, but sometimes, local
irritation can be caused at the target site (especially in case of transdermal patches). Micro needles can cause pain during
applying the procedure, visibility of post-inflammatory hyper pigmentation,
transient erythema and oedema.
Besides it, composition of transdermal patches, might
cause erythema, oedema or
itching on the applied surface. Transdermal patches
always require low molecular weight drug compounds, less than 500 Da. These
patches might result in allergic reaction at the local site (5, 8).
CONCLUSION:
Transdermal
therapy has various benefits over its adverse effects. Diseases like Acne vulgaris can be easily cured with the help of this method.
Techniques like transdermal patches can be easily
applied in case of mild to moderate acne conditions whereas micro needles can
be used for the treatment of moderate to severe acne cases. Recently,
researchers are continuously trying for successful application of transdermal techniques to cure various skin inflammatory
diseases including acne vulgaris, which shows the
bright scope for the use of transdermal drug delivery
methods in future.
REFERENCES:
1.
Vishal
Gupta, S. K. Yadav, Ashvani
Kumar Dwivedi and Naveen
Gupta (2011). Transdermal Drug Delivery: Past,
Present and Future Trends. International Journal of Pharmacy and Life Sciences.
2(9).
2.
Ratna
Mehta (2004). Topical and Transdermal Drug Delivery:
What a Pharmacist Needs to Know. The Accreditation Council for Pharmacy
Education (ACPE). InetCE 221-146-04-054-H01
3.
Anindita
De and Amandeep Kaur Gill
(2013). Proniosomal Gel of Tretinoin
for the Treatment of Acne Vulgaris. Journal of
Applied Pharmaceutical Sciences. 081-086: 3 (7)
4.
Leon H. Kircik (2011). Early Anti-inflammatory Topical Acne Therapy
May Improve Outcomes and Reduce Bacterial Resistance. Practical Dermatology for
Pediatrics. 16-20.
5.
Sonia Dhiman, Thakur Gurjeet Singh and Ashish Kumar Rehni (2011). Transdermal
Patches: A Recent Approch to New Drug Delivery
System. International Journal of Pharmacy and Pharmaceutical Sciences. 26-34:
3(5).
6.
José Juan
Escobar-Chávez, Isabel Marlen
Rodríguez-Cruz,
Clara Luisa Domínguez-Delgado, Roberto Díaz-Torres, Alma
Luisa Revilla-Vázquez, Norma Casas
Aléncaster (2012). Chapter 8: Nanocarrier
Systems for Transdermal Drug Delivery.
7.
Kristen M.
Whitney and Chérie M. Ditre
(2011). Anti-Inflammatory Properties of Clindamycin:
A Review of Its Use in the Treatment of Acne Vulgaris.
Clinical Medicine Insights: Dermatology. 27-41: 4.
8.
Imran
Majid and Gousia Sheikh
(2014). Microneedling and its applications in dermatology.
Dermatology. http://www.researchgate.net/publication/266624406.
9.
Kalpana
S Paudel, Mikolaj Milewski, Courtney L Swadley,
Nicole K Brogden, Priyanka Ghosh, and Audra L Stinchcomb
(2010). Challenges and opportunities in dermal/transdermal
delivery. National Institute of Health-Public Access, Authors Manuscript.
109-131: 1(1).
10.
Steven
Feldman, Rachel E. Careccia, Kelly L. Barham, and John Hancox (2004).
Diagnosis and Treatment of Acne. American Academy of Family Physicians (69:
2123-30, 2135-6).
11.
Gregor Cevc, Gabriele Blume, Andreas
Schätzlein, Dieter Gebauer,
Amla Paul (1996). The Skin: A Pathway for Systemic
Treatment with Patches and Lipid Based Agent Carriers. Science Direct, Advanced
Drug Delivery Reviews. 349-378: 18(3).
12.
Mark R. Prausnitz and Robert Langer (2008). Transdermal
Drug Delivery. Nat Biotechnol. 1261-1268: 26(11).
13.
Victoria J.
Lewis and Andrew Y. Finlay. Inflammatory Skin Diseases.
Received
on 07.10.2015
Accepted on 22.10.2015
©A&V Publications all right reserved
Research J. Topical and Cosmetic Sci. 7(1): Jan.-June
2016 page 23-26
DOI: 10.5958/2321-5844.2016.00005.4