A
Stability-indicating HPTLC method for estimation of Nadifloxacin
in topical cream
Rabindra K Nanda*, Amol A Kulkarni, Meenal N Ranjane and Poonam N. Ranjane
Padm. Dr. D. Y. Patil Institute of Pharmaceutical Sciences and Research, Pimpri, Pune-411018,
*Corresponding Author E-mail: amolk301@rediffmail.com
ABSTRACT:
The present work
describes a stability-indicating HPTLC method for analysis of nadifloxacin in topical cream. The separation was carried
out on Merck precoated silica gel aluminium plate 60
F254 using Chloroform: Methanol: Ammonia (4.3: 4.3: 1.4 v/v/v) as
mobile phase. The densitometric scanning was carried
out at 296 nm. Response was found to be linear in the concentration range of
50–300 ng /band with correlation coefficients (r2
= 0.9979). The method was validated as per ICH guidelines. The method was
successfully applied for the analysis of drugs in pharmaceutical formulation. Nadifloxacin was subjected to forced degradation by acid,
alkali, neutral, oxidation, dry heat, wet heat, sunlight, UV light. The
degradation products were well resolved from the pure drug with significantly
different RF values.
KEYWORDS: Nadifloxacin, HPTLC, Validation, Stability Studies.
1. INTRODUCTION:
Nadifloxacin (NAD), chemically know as (9-Fluoro-6,7-dihydro-8-(4-hydroxy piperidino)-5-methyl-1-oxo-1H, 5H-benzo [ij] quinolizine-2-carboxylic acid), is a Fluoroquinolone
antibiotic used for the treatment of skin infections with susceptible bacteria,
Acne vulgaris ( Inflamed lesions) (1 – 2).
Literature survey reveals HPLC determination
of Nadifloxacin in rat plasma (3) & UV–visible spectroscopic studies about
the interactions between polyamidoamine (PAMAM) dendrimers and quinolones (nadifloxacin and prulifloxacin)
(4). No HPTLC method is reported so far for the estimation of
drug in pharmaceutical formulations; hence we have developed a stability
indicating HPTLC method for the estimation of nadifloxacin
in bulk and pharmaceutical formulation. Structure of Nadifloxacin
is shown in Figure 1.
2.
EXPERIMENTAL:
2.1. Reagents and Chemicals:
Nadifloxacin was supplied as a gift sample by Cipla Ltd (
2.2. Instrumentation and Chromatographic
Conditions:
The standard solutions ranging from 50-300 ng/band were applied on precoated
silica gel 60 GF254 plate in the form of bands with 100 µl sample
syringe using automatic sample applicator LINOMAT V. The linear ascending
development was carried out in 10 cm ×10 cm twin trough glass chamber which was
already saturated for 30 min. with the mobile phase. The mobile phase consists
of Chloroform: Methanol: Ammonia (4.3: 4.3: 1.4v/v/v). After development plate
was immediately dried with the help of dryer and was observed under UV chamber.
The well resolved band of drug was scanned at 296 nm with Camag
TLC scanner III densitometer controlled by WINCAT’s software. The source of
radiation utilized was deuterium lamp emitting a continuous UV spectrum between
200 to 400 nm.
2.3. Standard
Solutions and Calibration Graphs:
Stock solution was prepared by dissolving 100 mg of nadifloxacin in 100 mL methanol,
from which 1 mL was further diluted to 100 mL with methanol to get stock solution of 10 ng/µL. The standard solutions were applied in a
concentration range of 50–300 ng/band for nadifloxacin. The plate was developed on previously
described mobile phase. The peak areas were plotted against the corresponding
concentrations to obtain the calibration graphs.
2.4.
Analysis of Formulation:
A quantity of cream equivalent to 10 mg of NAD (1 g of
cream) was weighed and transferred to a 100 ml volumetric flask about 30 ml of
methanol was added, just warmed 5-10 mins, ultrasonicated for 20 mins and
volume was made up to the mark with the methanol. The solution was filtered
using Whatman paper No. 41. From the filtrate 1 ml was further diluted to 10 ml
to get sample stock solution of NAD 10 ng/µl. From sample stock solution 10 µl volumes was
applied on HPTLC plate to obtain final concentration of 100 ng/band
for NAD. Six sample solutions were applied and after chromatographic
development peak areas of the spots were measured at 296 nm and concentrations
in the samples were determined using multilevel calibration.
Figure 1. Structure of NAD
Figure 2. Standard densitogram of NAD
Figure 3. In situ spectrum of NAD standard and sample
measured from 200 to 400nm
Figure 4. H2O2
degradation
Table 1:
Linear regression data for calibration curves for NAD (n = 3)
Parameter |
NAD |
Detection Wavelength (nm) |
296 |
Beer’s Law Limit (ng/band) |
50-300 |
Regression equation |
y = 26.212x + 1407.3 |
Correlation Coefficient (r) |
0.9979 |
Intercept (c) ± SD |
26.212 ± 0.89 |
Slope (m) ± SD |
1407.273 ± 114.34 |
Limit of detection (ng/band) |
14.39 |
Limit of quantitation (ng/band) |
43.62 |
3. METHOD
VALIDATION:
The proposed
method was optimized and validated as per the International Conference on
Harmonization (ICH) guidelines (5). The following parameters were validated
Table 2:
Results of marketed formulation analysis
Marketed formulation |
Drug |
Label claim (% w/w) |
Area* of densitogram |
% Mean amount estimated*± S.D* |
Nadibact |
NAD |
1 |
4072.07 |
101.24 ± 1.41 |
*Average of six
determinations
Table 3:
Statistical evaluation of precision of developed method
Drug - NAD |
Precision |
|
Intraday* |
Interday** |
|
Conc.(ng/band) |
100 |
80, 100, 120 |
Mean area ± SD |
4069.95 ± 25.79 |
4051.02 ± 11.24 |
% Content ± SD |
101.35 ± 0.97 |
100.56 ± 1.11 |
RSD (%) |
0.96 |
1.11 |
S.E. |
0.3967 |
0.3713 |
*Average of six
determinations **Average of nine
determinations
3.1. Precision:
The precision was determined at two levels, i.e. repeatability and
intermediate precision. Repeatability was determined by six replicate applications of a sample solution at the
analytical concentration. Inter-day variation was carried out with six
determinations at 100% of test concentration and intraday variation for
determination of NAD was carried out with six replicates at concentration
levels 100 ng/band on different days.
Table 4:
Result from recovery studies (n = 3)
Level of recovery (%) |
Total amt of drug recovered (ng/band) |
Amount of drug estimated in
mg/g of cream |
Amount of pure drug recovered |
% Recovery* |
SD |
S.E. |
% RSD |
80 |
181.26 |
101.47 |
79.79 |
99.65 |
0.55 |
0.3164 |
0.55 |
100 |
200.91 |
101.39 |
99.52 |
99.49 |
0.46 |
0.2677 |
0.46 |
120 |
221.14 |
101.50 |
119.64 |
99.65 |
0.40 |
0.2338 |
0.41 |
*Average of three
determinations
Table 5:
Robustness of method
A: Chromatographic Changes (% of chloroform
in mobile phase)
% change in mobile phase (Methanol: Chloroform:
Ammonia) |
Rf |
Peak area |
43 : 43 : 14 |
0.62 |
4092.8 |
42.14 : 43.86 : 14 |
0.61 |
4046.6 |
43.86 : 42.14 :14 |
0.63 |
4062.7 |
43 : 43.28 :13.72 |
0.61 |
4050.83 |
43.28 : 43 :13.72 |
0.63 |
4081.7 |
Mean*± S.D. |
0.62 ± 0.01 |
4066.92 ± 19.87 |
*Average
of three determinations
3.2.
Robustness:
The robustness of
the method was studied, during method development, by small but deliberate
variations in mobile phase composition (± 2%), chamber saturation period (± 10%),
development distance (± 10%), time from application to development
(0, 10, 15, 20 min), time from development to scanning (0, 30, 60, 90 min). One
factor at a time was changed at a concentration level of 100ng/band of NAD, to
study the effect on the peak area of the drugs.
3.3. Limit of
Detection and Limit of Quantitation:
The LOD and LOQ
were separately determined based on the calibration curves.
3.4. Specificity:
The specificity
of the method was ascertained by analyzing standard drug and sample. The spot
for nadifloxacin in sample was confirmed by comparing
the Rf and spectra of the spot with that of
standard. The peak purity of nadifloxacin was
assessed by comparing the spectra at three different levels, i.e., peak start (S),
peak apex (M) and peak end (E) positions of the spot.
3.5. Recovery
Studies:
To check the
degree of accuracy of the method, recovery studies were performed in triplicate
by standard addition method at 80%, 100% and 120%. A known amount of standard
NAD was added to pre-analyzed samples and was subjected to the proposed HPTLC
method. At each level of recovery three determinations were performed.
4. Forced
Degradation Studies:
The International
Conference on Harmonization (ICH) guideline entitled ‘‘Stability Testing of New
Drug Substances and Products’’ requires the performance of stress testing to
elucidate the inherent stability characteristics of the active substance [6].
An ideal stability indicating method is one that quantifies not only the drug
compound alone but also resolves its degradation products.
B: Chromatographic Changes (chamber
saturation)
Chamber saturation |
Rf |
Peak area |
13.5 mins |
0.63 |
4021.0 |
15 mins |
0.62 |
4075.0 |
16.5 mins |
0.62 |
4066.0 |
Mean*± S.D. |
0.62 ± 0.01 |
4054.0 ± 28.93 |
*Average of three
determinations
Preparation of stock solution:
A stock solution
containing 100 mg of nadifloxacin in 100 mL methanol was prepared, further diluted 1 mL of above solution up to 100 mL
with methanol. This stock solution (10 μg/mL) was used for forced degradation to provide an
indication of the stability indicating
property and specificity of the proposed method.
4.1. Acid
Degradation Studies:
To 10 mL of methanolic stock solution
of nadifloxacin added 10 mL
of 5 N HCl. This mixture was refluxed 24 hr. 20 µL
(100 ng/spot) of the resultant solutions were applied
on TLC plate and was developed and scanned under above established
chromatographic conditions.
4.2. Alkali
Degradation Studies:
To 10 mL of methanolic stock solution
of nadifloxacin added 10 mL
of 5 N NaOH. This mixture was refluxed 24 hr. 20 µL
(100 ng/spot) of the resultant solutions were
applied on TLC plate.
4.3. Neutral
Degradation Studies:
To 10 mL of methanolic stock solution
of nadifloxacin added 10 mL
of water. This mixture was refluxed 24 hr. 20 µL (100 ng/spot)
of the resultant solutions were applied on TLC plate and was developed and
scanned under above established chromatographic conditions.
4.4. Oxidation
Studies:
To 10 mL of methanolic stock solution
of nadifloxacin, 10 mL
of hydrogen peroxide (H2O2) (30%, v/v) was added. This
solution was heated in boiling water bath for 10 min to remove completely
the excess of hydrogen peroxide and then refluxed for 8 hr at 80 °C.
20 µL (100 ng/spot) of the resultant solutions
were applied on TLC plate and was developed and scanned under above established
chromatographic conditions.
4.5. Dry heat-induced Degradation:
The bulk nadifloxacin was stored at 100 °C for 24 hr under dry
heat conditions. The methanolic stock solution of
this dry heat exposed drug was prepared as described above and 10 mL of the prepared stock solution was diluted to 20 mL with methanol (5 μg/mL). 20 µL (100 ng/spot) of
the resultant solutions were applied on TLC plate and was developed and scanned
under above established chromatographic conditions.
4.6. Wet heat-induced Degradation:
10 mL
of the methanolic stock solution of nadifloxacin was diluted to 20 mL
with methanol (5 μg/mL)
and refluxed for 3 hr at boiling water bath to study the wet heat
degradation. 20 µL (100 ng/spot) of the
resultant solutions were applied on TLC plate and was developed and scanned
under above established chromatographic conditions.
C: Chromatographic Changes (development
distance)
Development distance |
Rf |
Peak area |
88 mm |
0.62 |
4069.2 |
80 mm |
0.63 |
4034.7 |
72 mm |
0.64 |
4035.6 |
Mean*± S.D. |
0.63 ± 0.01 |
4046.5 ± 19.66 |
*Average
of three determinations
D: Chromatographic Changes (Time from
application to development)
Time from application to
development |
Rf |
Peak area |
0 |
0.62 |
4050.3 |
10 mins |
0.64 |
4069.7 |
15 mins |
0.64 |
4056.7 |
20 mins |
0.65 |
4039.8 |
Mean*± S.D. |
0.64 ± 0.01 |
4054.1 ± 12.50 |
*Average
of three determinations
4.7. Photochemical and UV
Degradation Product:
10 mL of the methanolic stock solution of nadifloxacin
was diluted to 20 mL with methanol (5 μg/mL) and the photochemical
stability of
the drug was studied by exposing the stock solution to direct sunlight for 4
days on a wooden plank and kept on terrace. The drug solution was also exposed
to UV irradiation at 254 nm for 8 h in a UV-chamber. 20 µL (100 ng/spot) of the resultant solutions were applied on TLC
plate and was developed and scanned under above established chromatographic
conditions.
4.8. Detection of Related
Impurities:
The related unknown impurities were
determined by spotting higher concentrations of the nadifloxacin.
Nadifloxacin solution was prepared of a concentration
100 μg/mL in
methanol, and this solution was termed as sample solution. 1 mL of the sample solution was diluted to 10 mL with methanol and this solution was termed as standard
solution (10 μg/mL).
10 µL of the sample solution (1000ng/spot) and standard solution (100 ng/spot) were applied on HPTLC plate and was developed and
scanned under above established chromatographic conditions.
5.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION:
5.1. Optimization of
Procedures:
While selection of mobile phase different
proportions of methanol, chloroform, ammonia were tried. Ultimately mobile
phase containing Chloroform: Methanol: Ammonia (4.3: 4.3: 1.4 v/v/v) was
finalized as optimal for obtaining well defined and resolved peaks. The spots
developed were dense, compact and typical
E: Chromatographic Changes (Time from
development to scanning)
Time from development to
scanning |
Rf |
Peak area |
0 |
0.62 |
4061.27 |
30min |
0.62 |
4064.27 |
1 hr |
0.62 |
4064.27 |
1 hr 30 mins |
0.62 |
4070.17 |
Mean*± S.D. |
0.62 ± 0.00 |
4065.00 ± 3.73 |
*Average of three
determinations
Table 6:
Results of forced degradation studies
Stress condition |
Time |
% Assay of active substance |
Rf values of degradation products |
Acid hydrolysis (5N HCl) |
24 hrs |
100.70 |
No degradation |
Base hydrolysis (5N NaOH) |
24 hrs |
100.74 |
No degradation |
Neutral (H2O) |
24 hrs |
101.75 |
No degradation |
Oxidation (30% H2O2,80°C) |
8 hrs |
86.72 |
0.59 |
Dry Heat (100°C) |
24 hrs |
97.24 |
No degradation |
Wet Heat (On boiling water bath) |
3 hrs |
100.85 |
No degradation |
Photo stability |
4 days |
63.46 |
0.49 |
UV radiation |
8 hrs |
101.05 |
No degradation |
5.2. Method Validation
NAD showed good correlation coefficient in
concentration range of 50–300 ng/band (r2
= 0.9979) (Table 1). The spot at Rf 0.62 was observed in the densitogram
of the drug sample extracted from cream. There was no interference from the
excipients commonly present in the creams. The % assay for nadifloxacin was
found to be 101.24 ± 1.40 % RSD (Table
2). The low %RSD value indicated the suitability of this method for routine
analysis. Good correlation was obtained between standard and sample spectra of nadifloxacin. The comparative spectrum of standard and
sample was given in Figure 3. %RSD
was found to be less than 2 % for day to day variations, which proves that
method was precise. Results were shown in Table
3. Results of recovery studies were
shown in Table 4. Method was found robust and results were
given in Table 5.
5.3. Stability-Indicating
Property
HPTLC studies of the samples obtained during the stress
testing of NAD under different conditions using Chloroform: Methanol: Ammonia
(4.3: 4.3: 1.4v/v/v) as the mobile phase suggested the following degradation
behavior (Table 6).
NAD was found to be stable in acidic, alkaline and
neutral condition. Also the drug was stable in UV light for the period of 8 hr.
The drug was degraded in 30% hydrogen peroxide at 80°C and shows degradation
peak (D1) at Rf 0.59 as shown in Figure 4. The drug when subjected to dry heat, it does not show any
degradation peak but the assay of active drug gets reduced to 97.24%. When drug
was subjected to wet heat it shows broadening of peak at bottom but the area
was not get hampered. In sunlight drug was get degraded and degradation peak
(D2) was observed at 0.49 Rf as shown in Figure 5.
Figure 5. Photo stability
5.4. Related Impurities:
Only principal spots for nadifloxacin
were observed in sample and standard solution, which indicates that drug does
not show any related impurities to nadifloxacin.
6. CONCLUSION:
The proposed HPTLC method was validated as per ICH
guidelines. The %RSD and standard error calculated for the method were low,
indicating high degree of precision of the methods. The results of the recovery
studies performed show the high degree of accuracy of the proposed methods. The
results of the stress studies indicated the specificity of the method. Hence,
it can be concluded that the developed HPTLC method was accurate, precise and
selective and can be employed successfully for the estimation of Nadifloxacin in topical cream.
7. ACKNOWLEDGEMENT:
The authors are thankful to Dr. A.D. Despande, Director of Pharmacy, Padmashri
Dr. D. Y. Patil Institute of Pharmaceutical Sciences
and Research, Pimpri, Pune
for providing necessary facilities and to Cipla Ltd (
1.
O’Neil
MJ.
2.
Jacobs
MR. and Appelbaum PC. Nadifloxacin: a quinolone for
topical treatment of skin infections and potential for systemic use of its
active isomer, WCK 771. Expert Opin.
Pharmacotherapy. 2006; 7: 1957.
3.
Lunn G. and Wiley J. HPLC Methods for Recently Approved Pharmaceuticals. J.
Wiley & Sons INC publication,
4.
Cheng Y. Qu
H. Ma M. Xu Z. Xu P. Fang Y. and Xu T. European Journal of
Medicinal Chemistry 2007; 42: 1032-1038.
5. ICH Q2 (R1), Harmonised
Tripartite Guideline, Validation of
Analytical Procedures: Text and
Methodology. 2005.
6. ICH–QA1 (R2) Stability testing of new drug
substance and products. International Conference on Harmonization,
Received on 24.12.2009 Accepted on 20.02.2010
©A&V
Publications all right reserved
Res. J. Topical and Cosmetic Sci. 1(1): Jan. – June
2010 page 25-29